CRUSH SCHOOL

I blog on Brain-Based Learning, Metacognition, EdTech, and Social-Emotional Learning. I am the author of the Crush School Series of Books, which help students understand how their brains process information and learn. I also wrote The Power of Three: How to Simplify Your Life to Amplify Your Personal and Professional Success, but be warned that it's meant for adults who want to thrive and are comfortable with four letter words.

The Systems Approach in Education: Nurturing Holistic Learning

In a world of rapid change and increasing complexity, traditional education often falls short in adequately preparing students for the challenges we are currently facing. Population growth, resource demands and exploitation, climate change, disease, sustainability, poverty, peace and security, human rights… are all interconnected. One affects another no matter how hard we try to separate them and deal with each issue one by one, and perhaps this is why it is time to give up the status quo way of educating in favor of the systems approach.

Understanding the Systems Approach

The systems approach finds any system as not just a collection of individual parts, but an integrated whole where the interactions between these parts create emergent behaviors (behaviors that emerge from the interactions of various parts of the system).

In traditional education, we often compartmentalize subjects and treat their topics in isolation. In contrast, the systems approach encourages an interdisciplinary perspective. It emphasizes the interconnectedness of subjects, encouraging students to understand how knowledge and skills from various domains can be used to solve real-world problems. This approach mirrors the complexity of real-life situations, where challenges rarely fit into a single academic field.

Key Principles of the Systems Approach in Education

  1. Interdisciplinary Learning: The systems approach promotes learning that transcends disciplines. By encouraging students to explore connections between subjects, it equips them with a more comprehensive understanding of complex issues.

  2. Holistic Problem Solving: In the real world, challenges are multifaceted. The systems approach teaches students to analyze problems from multiple angles and consider the broader implications of their solutions.

  3. Contextual Understanding: Education should not occur in a vacuum. The systems approach encourages students to consider the cultural, societal, and global contexts in which their knowledge can be applied.

  4. Adaptability and Resilience: Complex systems are adaptable and resilient. The systems approach equips students with the ability to adapt to new situations and learn from failures.

  5. Collaborative Learning: Systems thinking involves understanding of relationships and interactions, which encourages collaborative learning. Students learn to work effectively in teams, leveraging diverse perspectives to achieve optimal solutions.

Effective Implementation of the Systems Approach

  1. Curriculum Design: A systems-focused curriculum incorporates Phenomenon-Based Learning (PhenBL), which promotes case studies, real-world simulations, and interdisciplinary projects. Investigating multifaceted phenomena exposes students to the complex connections between topics associated with seemingly disparate subjects and how a more holistic understanding can be used to create more meaningful solutions.

  2. Assessment Methods: Traditional exams cannot correctly evaluate systems thinking skills. Performance assessments, such as designing and performing investigations, creating multimedia products, and solving real-world problems can better measure a student's ability to connect various subjects and issues.

  3. Teacher Training: Teachers are key to promoting the systems approach. Adequate PD should focus on enhancing teachers' ability to design more holistic lesson plans, facilitate collaborative learning, and guide students in applying systems thinking.

  4. Technology: Technology can facilitate the systems approach by providing tools for visualizing and simulating complex systems and connecting with experts from various fields, transcending geographical limitations.

Benefits of The Systems Approach

Embracing the systems approach in education offers numerous benefits. Students develop critical thinking skills, a deeper understanding of real-world complexity, and an enhanced ability to innovate. By fostering collaboration and adaptability, this approach prepares students for careers in a rapidly changing job market.

Future Implications of The Systems Approach

However, transitioning to a systems approach requires a paradigm shift in education. Curricula need to be replaced by approaches such as Phenomenon- or Project-Based Learning. The evaluation metrics for student success need to evolve in kind to gauge the complex, multifaceted, and transferable skills developed through using the systems approach.

The systems approach aims to bridge the gap between the classroom and the real-world. By cultivating holistic thinking, interdisciplinary learning, collaboration, and learning from mistakes, the systems approach equips students with the skills necessary to navigate the complexities of the modern era. The world of education must continue to embrace and improve holistic learning models such as the systems approach to move the society closer to a future in which students learn how to solve (and solve) global challenges in the classroom.


If you found this post helpful, sign up for my Teaching Tips, Resources, & Ideas Newsletter to get the next article when it drops. It’s totally free.

BOOKS & TOOLS

Phenomena Poster
$3.00
Add To Cart
Mistakes Are... Poster
$3.00
Add To Cart
Back 2 School Classroom Bundle of 8 Posters
Sale Price:$8.00 Original Price:$16.00
Because... Chemistry Unisex T-Shirt
from $15.00
Color:
Size:
Quantity:
Add To Cart

Creating Performance Assessments for Phenomenon-Based Learning

As concerns grow that traditional assessments such as tests frequently fall short of capturing the depth of students' understanding and fail in measuring their ability to apply knowledge in real-world scenarios, Phenomenon-Based Learning (PhenBL) has emerged as a student-centered approach that prioritizes building comprehension through active inquiry. To align with this innovative instructional method, educators are turning to performance assessments – powerful tools that have the potential to unleash creativity, transformative skill-building, and deeper learning.

Understanding Phenomenon-Based Learning

Phenomenon-Based Learning is an inquiry-driven approach that uses real-world phenomena to engage students in exploration. Rather than starting by explaining facts and concepts to students, PhenBL is predicated on the learners investigating phenomena and forming understandings of the underlying principles (facts and concepts) behind these phenomena.

The Limitations of Traditional Assessments

Traditional assessments, such as multiple-choice exams, often assess rote memorization and superficial knowledge. They rarely measure skills such as critical thinking and problem-solving or in-depth knowledge. These assessments also fail to show students' ability to apply knowledge to real-life situations, which is a central goal of PhenBL and should be the goal of all learning.

Benefits of Performance Assessments

Performance assessments offer a transformative alternative to traditional testing methods. They focus on students' ability to apply knowledge, skills, and strategies to authentic, real-world scenarios. By leveraging performance assessments in phenomenon-based learning, we can:

  1. Measure Deeper Understanding: Performance assessments allow educators to observe how well students comprehend and apply scientific concepts in practical contexts. For instance, students could conduct experiments, analyze data, and draw meaningful conclusions based on their observations.

  2. Promote Critical Thinking: Performance assessments encourage students to think critically and creatively as they tackle complex problems related to the phenomenon. This enhances their ability to make connections, analyze information, and devise innovative solutions.

  3. Teach Collaboration: Many performance assessments involve group projects or problem-solving, which cultivates effective teamwork and communication skills. Collaboration also enables students to share their unique perspectives and learn from each other.

  4. Provide Timely, Constructive Feedback: Many meaningful performance assessments take more than one day to complete allowing opportunities for formative assessment. As teachers check in with various teams, they can provide timely feedback that guides students' progress. Such personalization enables teachers to assess understanding, keeps students on track, drives continuous improvement, and supports students' growth.

  5. Enhance Engagement: Performance assessments take advantage of student interests and provide real-life relevance. Engaging in hands-on investigation and creation builds intrinsic motivation and enthusiasm for learning of content as the PhenBL vehicle connects the world of school with the world outside of it.

Examples of Performance Assessments in Phenomenon-Based Learning

  1. Design and Conduct an Investigation: Students can be tasked with designing and conducting their own investigations related to the phenomenon in question. They can develop hypotheses, plan experiments, gather data, and draw conclusions, showcasing their inquiry and experimental skills and gaining deeper knowledge of the concepts. For example, you could challenge students to design a school-wide survey on a social or psychological topic or to use the web as a resource to design an experiment that demonstrates and helps them explain (and thus learn) a science concept.

  2. Create a Multimedia Presentation: Students can create multimedia presentations such as explainer videos that contain models of phenomena concepts, or infographics that explain and exemplify a phenomenon to a broader audience. The key for teachers is to combine visual and verbal communication skills and challenge students not to read the information they wrote down, but rather convey the complex ideas in a simple way that is effective in both showing what the students learned and teaching the audience about the concepts and mechanisms responsible for the phenomenon studied. Check out my Coral Bleaching Project to get an idea for how to set this up.

  3. Solve Real-Life Problems: Challenge students to apply their understanding of the phenomenon to solve real-world problems. For example, they might devise sustainable solutions for an environmental issue around you school, such as lack of composting or recycling. Or they might propose an engineering design solution for some observed inefficiency. The idea is not to have students change the world in situ, though that’s highly desirable if possible, but to have them practice critical thinking, problem-solving, and design skills in an authentic way while learning content at the same time. For example, they could research and design a safer, or more interesting playground for the elementary school nearby. Their dream playground might not get built but their skills will be.

Learning and Growing through Performance Assessments

Performance assessments can provide a dynamic and effective means of evaluating students' learning in Phenomenon-Based Learning. By focusing on application, critical thinking, and collaboration, these assessments align perfectly with the goals of PhenBL. Embracing performance assessments empowers students to demonstrate the depth of their understanding and equips them with the skills they need to succeed in an ever-changing world. As educators continue to explore the potential of Phenomenon-Based Learning, performance assessments stand out as a valuable ally in nurturing a new generation of engaged, inquisitive, and capable professionals.


If you found this post helpful, sign up for my Teaching Tips, Resources, & Ideas Newsletter to get the next article when it drops. It’s totally free.

BOOKS & TOOLS

Phenomena Poster
$3.00
Add To Cart
Mistakes Are... Poster
$3.00
Add To Cart
Back 2 School Classroom Bundle of 8 Posters
Sale Price:$8.00 Original Price:$16.00
Because... Chemistry Unisex T-Shirt
from $15.00
Color:
Size:
Quantity:
Add To Cart

Phenomenon-Based Learning: Lesson-Level vs Anchoring Phenomena

Using phenomena to engage students and drive learning is what Phenomenon-Based Learning (PhenBL) is all about.

First, identify the core idea along with its supporting ideas you want students to learn.

Second, choose a phenomenon that will lead students to discovering these ideas.

Third, give students the time and the tools to investigate. Initially, you might have to guide their investigations and help them break down phenomena.

Fourth, have your students examine and construct models that show and explain various concepts that describe and solve the phenomenon studied.

Fifth, find out what your students learned by using a thoughtful performance assessment (next post).

And don’t forget to involve peer and teacher collaboration, discussion, questioning, feedback, and common learning experiences to keep everybody on track while exploring phenomena.

Two types of phenomena

If you are fairly new to Phenomenon-Based Learning and the above steps make your head spin, you are not alone. PhenBL lesson design requires a lot of thoughtful planning and the first few months are the hardest, as is the case with starting, learning, and becoming good at every new thing life throws at us. But it gets easier, and once you get a full school year under your belt, you can mostly reuse and recycle from year to year and just tweak that which needs tweaking.

But your anchoring and lesson phenomena can stay the same. Unless better phenomena occur shortly before you are due to teach a related concept and you just do not want to (nor should you) pass up such easily-relatable opportunities.

Anchoring phenomena and lesson phenomena are both components of Phenomena-Based Learning, but they serve different roles in the instructional process.

Lesson Phenomena

Perhaps the fastest way to get comfortable with PhenBL is to choose and use lesson-level phenomena. This will allow you to repeat the lesson design cycle over and over in a short time span and lead to a level of comfort that helps you avoid the “how do I do this again?” brain pain.

Generally, lesson phenomena are used to drive single lessons that may last one or a few days. They are chosen to support the learning objectives of each lesson and require students to gain understanding of the concepts named by these objectives. While not too easy, lesson phenomena can be solved in a day or a few days.

Lesson-Level Phenomenon Example

Watching vinegar and baking soda react and form carbon dioxide is a good example of lesson-level phenomenon that might be used to introduce the concept of chemical reactions. As the vinegar (acetic acid) and the baking soda (sodium bicarbonate) react, students observe bubbles (carbon dioxide) forming. Teachers might have students measure the temperature before and after the reaction and write down the observations and questions these observations bring up. Then, students could use online resources (or the textbook) to answer the questions they generated.

Teachers can support students in their investigations by checking on the specifics each group is researching and asking leading questions that help students learn how to distinguish chemical reactions from physical changes or how to set up a simple experiment to test the identity of the produced gas. Then, students may be encouraged to repeat the original experiment utilizing their gas test - lighting a wooden splint and inserting it into the carbon dioxide enriched atmosphere.

This observable phenomenon serves as a concrete example to teach students about chemical reactions and can be “solved” in one or two days, depending on the scope of the lesson.

Anchoring Phenomena

Anchoring phenomena, or anchor phenomena, are used as starting points for entire units of study. They are carefully selected to engage students' curiosity and serve as a focal point for learning and inquiry throughout the unit. An anchoring phenomenon is much more difficult to solve and requires several weeks to be fully understood and explained by students. Each “anchor” is supported with multiple, related lesson-level phenomena and concepts these phenomena represent that help break down the anchor concepts into more digestible chunks.

Anchoring Phenomenon Example

Watching a series of images or a brief video about recent record temperatures, forest fires, droughts, floods, and other extreme weather events is a great way to introduce a unit on global climate and climate change or a unit that focuses on impacts of human activity on the Earth systems.

As any good anchor should send students down a rabbit hole of big and small ideas that support an overarching unit concept, this phenomenon, one that leads to the understanding the ins and outs of global climate change, should lead students to the investigation into global warming, greenhouse effect, heating of the oceans, shifting weather patterns, burning of fossil fuels, increased occurrence of extreme weather, and other human impacts and causes of climate change.

Such an anchoring phenomenon will take weeks and multiple, connected lessons to “solve” and will need to be supported with several lesson-level phenomena to focus students on deeply understanding one major global-climate-change-related concept at a time.

Anchoring vs Lesson Phenomena

In summary, anchoring phenomena are overarching real-world events that initiate an entire unit of study, providing a context for the exploration of concepts. They engage students and set the stage for deeper inquiry. On the other hand, lesson phenomena are specific examples or instances of observable events used within individual lessons to reinforce the concepts covered in that particular session. They support the learning objectives of each lesson and contribute to students' understanding of the broader core idea introduced by the anchoring phenomenon.


If you found this post helpful, sign up for my Teaching Tips, Resources, & Ideas Newsletter to get the next article on Creating Performance Assessments when it drops. It’s totally free.

BOOKS & TOOLS

Phenomena Poster
$3.00
Add To Cart
Mistakes Are... Poster
$3.00
Add To Cart
Back 2 School Classroom Bundle of 8 Posters
Sale Price:$8.00 Original Price:$16.00
Because... Chemistry Unisex T-Shirt
from $15.00
Color:
Size:
Quantity:
Add To Cart

2024 Crush School